I feel sorry for the developers because theyre obviously working very hard at something that needs a serious redesign from the foundation up. There is no cohesiveness in this app. Youve got umpteen unassociated words that they like to use repeatedly -- the stepper, the dial, the yellow brick road, bees, akrasia (especially "akrasia," which makes my jaw clench every time they vomit that all over their blog and descriptions). They didnt plan this whole thing very well, and now what are they going to do to pull it out of the mess it is? It would take admitting that what they have isnt working and then finding a new developer ( or developers) who is not one of the dynamic duo who is obviously not up to the task. I find this so frustrating because its a good concept thats gone wrong by too many stupid decisions and an overall jump to create before having a good plan. The app is buggy as heck. Right now I cant even make a goal within the app. "Go make them on a desktop and then just update within the app," you say, and I repeat that a competent developer wouldnt require this. Also, Im worn thin by how much they pat themselves on the back in their blog and elsewhere as they wax on ad nauseum about exponents and such. They dont get that we the general public couldnt care less about all of that, and furthermore, its just annoying. Just redesign everything into something that is intuitive without the stupid disconnected jargon. I have tried repeatedly to like--or even tolerate--this app, and Im deleting once more. They just dont get it.
My original review:
The concept gets 5 stars, but the app needs a lot of work. Every time I open it, it gives errors regarding loading goals. When I create a new goal from within the app, it immediately derails. Also, there is a steeper-than-necessary learning curve with both the app and the web site. For example, its not immediately clear that you enter the date followed by a space and the quantity. Its not obvious that the input is automatically added to previous entries. Beeminder terms like "dial up" arent intuitive, either -- if Im wanting to decrease something a week+ into the future, "dial it in" seems like exactly what I wouldnt want to do. The app and site need to be much more intuitive. Suggestion is to have more beta testers that arent programmers, CS majors, statisticians and the like. Id love to give this 5 stars, but the constant error messages make me want to delete it and just use Beeminder from my desktop. Ill be happy to raise my rating if future versions are more user-friendly.